American Horror Story Season 13: Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters Teases Fans

by | Oct 27, 2025

Updated: October 27, 2025
American Horror Story Season 13: Ryan Murphy Teases Return

FX has not yet officially confirmed American Horror Story season 13, but the show was renewed for multiple seasons back in 2020. As of October 2025, there had been no new news or starts to production. However, Ryan Murphy, the creator, said that “a couple things are in contention.”

Fans are still hoping that people they know, like Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters, will come back when the next scary chapter starts.

Will There Be a Season 13 for American Horror Story?

Evan Peters in American Horror Story season 8

Image © 2018 FX Networks / 20th Television / Ryan Murphy Productions

Latest Updates and Confirmed Facts

There is still no word on Season 13 of American Horror Story, and as of October 2025, filming had not even begun. After the success of American Horror Story: 1984, FX ordered Seasons 11 through 13 of the horror anthology show in January 2020. Fans are excited, but neither the start date for filming nor the release date have been announced.

It is said that co-creators Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk are getting back together for the next season while also working on other projects, such as Grotesquerie and All’s Fair.

  • Current Status: Disney Television Studios executive Eric Schrier noted there’s “no incarnation ordered yet,” emphasizing the series’ flexibility and longevity.
  • Murphy’s Update: Ryan Murphy told The Hollywood Reporter that he had talked to Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters and hinted that Season 13 might be coming “sooner than you think.”
  • Landgraf’s Comment: FX Networks CEO John Landgraf praised the franchise as “such a brilliant idea,” adding that “Ryan loves to invent things and create worlds.”

Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters Teases

During several appearances in 2024 and 2025, Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters made people think they might be back for Season 13 of American Horror Story. She said, “I hope to be doing another season.”

Murphy also confirmed that he recently had a “wonderful conversation” with her and has plans to have dinner with Paulson and Peters.

  • Playful Hint: Paulson told Variety she felt it was “time to get the band back together,” referring to her and Peters’ classic AHS partnership.
  • Murphy’s Comment: Murphy added, “I’ll never give up on that show,” confirming his emotional connection to the series.
  • Possible Returnees: Both actors have been absent since Double Feature (2021) but remain fan favorites for the upcoming season.

What to Expect from American Horror Story Season 13?

Kim Kardashian and Emma Roberts  in American Horror Story season 12

Image © 2023 FX Networks / 20th Television / Ryan Murphy Productions

Possible Themes and Crossovers

Ryan Murphy said that he hasn’t decided on the plot for Season 13 of American Horror Story yet, but that there are “a couple things in contention.” The next installment in the FX anthology is still in its early stages of development.

Murphy has hinted at a return to the franchise’s “roots,” which could mean going back to the supernatural horror that made Murder House and Coven such fan faves.

  • Crossover Potential: Murphy has teased that “the witches will be back,” fueling talk of a major crossover involving characters from Coven, Apocalypse, or Hotel Cortez.
  • Creative Pause: FX chairman John Landgraf told Variety that Murphy is simply “resting the series.”
  • Murphy’s Approach: Known for blending timelines, Murphy could use Season 13 to connect the show’s many stories into one cohesive universe, a move long requested by viewers.

Fan Predictions and Symbolism of the Number 13

Thirteen has a long history of fear, myth, and change, all of which are things that American Horror Story loves to go into. Fans think that AHS Season 13 could be a symbolic “full-circle” moment, bringing together old and new characters for one last darkly great story.

  • Superstitious Undertone: People think that Murphy can bring back old-school horror tropes like ghosts, witches, or even cursed families from the show’s first seasons.
  • Finale Feel: The tone and timing of this episode suggest a reflective, large-scale one that could feel like a goodbye, even though Murphy hasn’t called it the last season.
  • Audience Anticipation: Longtime fans hope American Horror Story Season 13 recaptures the raw tension, mystery, and emotional depth that defined Murphy’s early work.

Who Will Return to the Cast of American Horror Story Season 13?

Matt Czuchry in American Horror Story season 12

Image © 2023 FX Networks / 20th Television / Ryan Murphy Productions

Likely Cast Members

Season 13 of American Horror Story hasn’t been officially cast yet, but a number of well-known actors have hinted that they might be interested. Ryan Murphy has talked about bringing back the “original gangster cast,” and Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, and Emma Roberts are still the front-runners to be cast.

  • Sarah Paulson: Paulson revealed she’s spoken to Murphy about returning, saying she’s ready to “get the band back together.”
  • Evan Peters: Peters shared his excitement about working with Paulson again after their break since Double Feature.
  • Emma Roberts: The star of Delicate may return depending on production schedules.
  • Denis O’Hare and Lily Rabe: Frequent collaborators of Murphy are rumored to reprise their roles.
  • Billie Lourd and Angela Bassett: Both are considered strong possibilities for supporting roles in the new season.

Legacy Actors Who Might Not Return

While some stars are ready for more, others have moved on. Jessica Lange, one of the show’s earliest legends, confirmed she won’t return. She last appeared in Apocalypse and stated she’s “done with it.” Patti LuPone also hinted she’s unlikely to rejoin, saying her time in the franchise felt complete.

  • Jessica Lange: Lange said in an interview, “Oh Christ, no,” when asked about returning, ending speculation of a comeback.
  • Patti LuPone: The actress explained in April 2025 that her schedule doesn’t allow another appearance.
  • New Blood: The next season may include new faces joining the familiar ones to attract younger viewers.

When Will American Horror Story Season 13 Be Released?

Cara Delevingne in American Horror Story

Image © 2023 FX Networks / 20th Television / Ryan Murphy Productions

Projected Premiere Timeline

Since the first season, every American Horror Story season has come out at the same time. Murder House, the first season, came out in October 2011. Freak Show and Cult, two others, came out in September. In line with past seasons, fans think that Season 13 of American Horror Story could come out in late 2026.

  • Historical Pattern: Most seasons launched between August and October, making fall the likeliest premiere window.
  • Production Update: The series has not begun production, but Murphy confirmed development talks are ongoing.
  • Scheduling Gap: FX filled AHS’s usual slot in 2024 with Grotesquerie, another Murphy project.
  • Fan Expectations: Viewers expect an announcement by early 2026 once filming officially starts.
  • Definition: Pre-production refers to the planning phase before filming begins, including casting and set design.

Where to Stream All Seasons

Fans of the show can watch old episodes of every season online while they wait for the next one. From “Murder House” to “Delicate,” all episodes can be streamed on Hulu in the U.S. and Disney+ in other countries. Some seasons are also available on FX Now for cable subscribers who like to watch TV.

  • Hulu Access: All 12 seasons are streaming on Hulu for American audiences.
  • Disney+: Available in the U.K., Canada, and other regions under the Disney Television Studios banner.
  • FX Now: Offers full episodes for those with cable logins.
  • Episode Guide: Most seasons have 9 to 13 episodes, each with standalone yet connected storylines.
  • Binge Tip: Fans can follow the AHS timeline chronologically to understand character crossovers.

How Has Every Season of American Horror Story Connected So Far?

Erin Murray in American Horror Story season 12

Image © 2023 FX Networks / 20th Television / Ryan Murphy Productions

Chronological Overview of All 12 Seasons

American Horror Story has changed the horror genre by combining stories that could stand alone into one big world. Murphy refers to “all these worlds” as the new settings, characters, and timelines that are taken on in each season.

The timeline goes from Murder House to Delicate and shows how Ryan’s creativity made the horror anthology series a cultural icon.

  • Season 1 – Murder House (2011): Introduced the Harmon family and a haunted Los Angeles mansion.
  • Season 2 – Asylum (2012): Shifted to a 1960s psychiatric hospital filled with dark experiments.
  • Season 3 – Coven (2013): Explored witchcraft and sisterhood in New Orleans.
  • Season 4 – Freak Show (2014): Followed carnival performers in 1950s Florida.
  • Season 5 – Hotel (2015): Set inside the eerie Hotel Cortez, ruled by glamorous ghosts.
  • Season 6 – Roanoke (2016): Mixed documentary style with supernatural horror.
  • Season 7 – Cult (2017):Season 8 – Apocalypse (2018): Combined Coven and Murder House in a crossover storyline.
  • Season 9 – 1984 (2019): Paid homage to slasher films.
  • Season 10 – Double Feature (2021): Split into Red Tide and Death Valley arcs.
  • Season 11 – NYC (2022): Set during the 1980s AIDS crisis.
  • Season 12 – Delicate (2023–24): Starred Emma Roberts and Kim Kardashian in a modern gothic thriller.

How American Horror Story connects characters and plots from different times is what makes it so intriguing. It was Murphy and Falchuk’s intention to create a universe where everything is connected and where old friends show up in strange ways.

It’s fun for fans to figure out how everything fits together, from Queenie’s death in Hotel Cortez to Pepper’s story linking Freak Show and Asylum.

  • Crossovers: Apocalypse united multiple seasons, proving every storyline exists in the same universe.
  • Character Threads: Actors like Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters played different roles tied through recurring themes.
  • Returning Motifs: Death, redemption, and identity anchor most storylines.
  • Creator Promise: Murphy once said, “The witches will be back,” hinting at future crossovers.

Final Thoughts

Without a release date, fans of American Horror Story Season 13 are still getting more and more excited. There is hope for the next chapter because Ryan Murphy had a great conversation with Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters about new ideas.

This horror anthology show is still the best in the business, as shown by their fun reunion on Emmy night. Stay tuned, because when fans asked for more American Horror, Murphy listened.

FAQs

Why did Evan Peters quit AHS?

Evan Peters said he needed a break from the horror genre after filming Double Feature but could return for American Horror Story Season 13 if Ryan Murphy calls.

Is AHS season 12 the last season?

No, fans asked this often, but Ryan Murphy confirmed a new season is in development under Disney Television Studios for the next season.

What is the most scary season of American Horror Story?

Many fans believe Freak Show and Murder House are the most terrifying seasons of American Horror because of their intense characters and storylines.

When is American Horror Story Season 13 happening?

American Horror Story Season 13 has not begun production yet, but Murphy promised a couple things are in progress for the upcoming season soon.

Who will return for American Horror Story Season 13?

Ryan Murphy had a wonderful conversation with Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters about returning, and both stars said it would be fun to reunite for fans again.

SHARE THIS POST